By most counts, Westerners are woefully underinvested in China. It's the second largest economy in the world, but because the People's Republic restricts foreign investment, Chinese stocks only account for 2% of the MSCI All Country World Index. That's about to change as the government begins easing its restrictions with the Shanghai-Hong Kong Stock Connect program this October.
Whether you feel grateful or confused that there are now 34 different Chinese stock ETFs to play this trend depends on your sophistication. Count Brian Singer as among the grateful. The manager of the William Blair Macro Allocation fund (ticker: WMCNX) likes the iShares China Large-Cap ETF (FXI) and the Guggenheim China Small Cap(HAO) for maximum flexibility. Currently, Singer favors FXI because large Chinese stocks will benefit most from the Connect program. Only 254 "Qualified Foreign Institutional Investors" are allowed to invest in stocks listed in mainland China, known as A shares. That amounts to $60 billion. The new program will allow an additional 300 billion yuan -- about $48 billion -- worth of foreign investment. "Institutional investors coming into the China market will favor large-cap stocks," Singer says.
Long-term, Singer prefers the Guggenheim fund because smaller companies are more exposed to the local Chinese economy than large multinationals. Overall, he says the Chinese stock market is priced 25% below his estimate of fair value.
The iShares and Guggenheim ETFs are not, however, invested in mainland China, but in Hong Kong-listed H shares. Singer says that the cost and red tape of investing on the mainland remain too high. Some ETF providers disagree: "There are 66 dually-listed stocks, which are available in both mainland China and in Hong Kong," says Brendan Ahern, managing director of KraneShares, which offers three China ETFs. "The mainland stocks trade at a 10% valuation discount." Ahern argues there is an arbitrage to exploit by buying A-shares and betting that the valuation gap closes as investment restrictions ease.
China A-shares also add necessary diversification. Since so few Westerners own them, they behave differently from other emerging-market stocks. Unlike H shares, A shares are priced in Chinese yuan instead of the Hong Kong dollar. The mainland currency is not pegged to the U.S. dollar. That's why the Market Vectors ChinaAMC A-Share ETF (PEK), the oldest A-share ETF, has a correlation of only 16% to other international stocks in the MSCI EAFE Index while the iShares China Large-Cap ETF has a 63% correlation, Morningstar notes.
There's another advantage to A shares: Easy exposure to China's strengthening currency. Of the five available, the PowerShares China A-Share Portfolio (CHNA) has the lowest expense ratio at 0.51%.
IN SMALLER EMERGING MARKETS, stocks tend to move in tandem, but in China there are large variations in returns depending on which sector you're in. TheGuggenheim China Technology ETF (CQQQ) has returned an annualized 18.3% over the past three years as dotcoms soared from the nation's increasing web usage. Meanwhile, Global X China Materials (CHIM) lost 7.7% annually.
New-economy tech, health care, and renewable energy companies have benefited in part because they are the focus of the government's most recent five- year plan for economic development. KraneShares CSI New China ETF (KFYP) only invests in sectors the plan highlights. Since China remains ostensibly a communist nation, it's good to pay attention to what the central planners are thinking.